Login with Facebook

Objections to utilitarianism

In the first chapter of the book, Mill began by recalling the nature and the philosophical importance of the problem of the Sovereign good and morality. After some considerations on the logical problem of the foundation in the sciences, he approached precisely the question of good and evil and showed the weaknesses of the various morals that Mill calls “intuitionists”, which have in common to consider that the distinction between the right and wrong is an inexplicable fact. According to him, this current includes Kantian morality - founded on reason - as well as that of Hume - founded on the moral sense.

 Mill wants to show that the “other” theory, that is to say, utilitarianism, can, on the contrary, explain the distinction between good and evil very precisely. This is what he will do in this second chapter.

 The whole of this chapter 2 can be conceived of as a series of prolepses, that is, of responses to objections which Mill himself envisages against the utilitarian doctrine which he defends. Mill borrows most of these objections from the history of ideas or from his contemporaries.

 As he presents these objections and details his responses to them, Mill exposes utilitarian doctrine in its various aspects. These objections can be characterized as follows:

- Objection based on a misunderstanding of the concept of "utility" in relation to pleasure

- Objection based on a too vile conception of human pleasures

- Objection based on an overly ambitious conception of happiness that would make it impossible

- Objection based on a selfish conception of happiness

- Objection based on an overly demanding conception of utilitarian morality

- Objection based on a poor distinction between action and agent

- Objection based on the alleged incompatibility between utilitarianism and religion

- Objection based on confusion between usefulness and interest

- Objection based on the alleged practical impossibility of utilitarianism

- Objection based on the risks of utilitarianism in a moral dilemma

 In the following chapters of the book, Mill will address respectively the question of knowing what can push an agent to respect a moral rule (chapter 3), that of knowing if and how one can prove the principle of utilitarian morality (chapter 4), and finally that of the link which unites justice and utility.

Doesn't utilitarian philosophy result in rejecting pleasures (objection 1)?

This objection is based on a misunderstanding, and even on a misunderstanding about the word "utility", which should especially not be taken in a cold, calculating sense. On the contrary, we will see that utility as a criterion of moral action is the capacity of this action to contribute to the happiness of all, happiness which is itself, precisely, composed of pleasures, informs to be specified (see objection 2): By “happiness” we mean pleasure and the absence of pain; by “misfortune”, pain and the deprivation of pleasure. "

Doesn't utilitarian philosophy invite people to lead a petty, degrading existence (objection 2)?

This objection - in a way contrary to the previous one - is to accuse utilitarianism of pushing human beings towards what they have that is lowest, more base, more unworthy. Pleasure, which utilitarian makes the main ingredient of happiness, is according to the proponents of this objection nothing more than a set of gross satisfactions - Mill probably thinks, without naming them, of the pleasures of the table and the bed. The human being deserves better than an existence based on this kind of satisfaction.

 Now it is precisely those who reduce the pleasure of the human being to its lowest, most animal dimensions, which make it a base being, Mill replies to them that pleasures are all the more typically human as they are not common with those of other animals. The pleasures which bring into play the higher faculties of the human being (his intelligence, his culture, his imagination, etc) are better than the others. How to be sure of this judgment? The only competent judges can only be those who know all the pleasures. We will not ask a fool what the value of pleasures requiring intelligence is. We will not ask a pig if food provides a higher quality of pleasure than philosophy. The fool or the pig may be satisfied, but not really happy.

 Thus, we can define utilitarian morality as the set of rules which allow human beings in their entirety to lead the happiest possible existence that is to say to experience the most varied and most pleasures high possible.

Happiness, which utilitarian philosophy poses as Sovereign good, is it not impossible to achieve (objection 3)?

To this objection, Mill replies on the one hand that happiness should not be conceived as too ideal - some temporary pains are certainly inevitable, but are not incompatible with happiness - and on the other hand that happiness is at least in part within our grasp - nature, the arts, the sciences constitute inexhaustible sources of pleasure. Finally, the external causes of our unhappiness, such as poverty or disease, must be able to be; if not suppressed, at least contained by the political and scientific progress that utilitarianism calls for.

Isn't utilitarian philosophy incompatible with disinterested self-sacrifice (objection 4)?

This objection overlooks a fact that is crucial: self-sacrifice is never an end in itself, and always a means: now, for what do we sacrifice ourselves, if not for the happiness of others?  The hero and the martyr act well according to a utilitarian ideal, even if they are led to neglect their own happiness. Their sacrifice is all the more meritorious, although it undoubtedly brings them the hope that humanity will one day be able to do without such sacrifices. Utilitarianism, in fact, aims for a social and political ideal in which, thanks to the progress of laws and education, it would no longer be essential to sacrifice one's happiness for that of others.

Doesn't utilitarian philosophy set an ideal too high, too noble for humanity (objection 5)?

This objection can be applied to any moral philosophy, assumptions, wrongly, that it would be required of human beings that the totality of their actions. It is done in view of the highest moral goal in the case of utilitarianism, with a view to the greatest happiness for all, which is too much to demand from human beings. 

 But neither utilitarian philosophy nor any other moral philosophy is so exacting of humanity: with the exception of political leaders, in particular, human beings very rarely have to worry about the happiness of the greatest. 

Doesn't utilitarian philosophy consist in judging only acts, without taking into account the agents themselves (objection 6)?

Mill responds to this objection with a subtle conceptual distinction. It should not be confused:

- The plan, which concerns only the action itself, and for assessing the morality of this Action.

- The motive, that is to say the feeling which prompts the agent to perform an action, which makes it possible to assess the agent's worth.

 Thus Mill asserts that intentionally saving someone from a drowning is a morally good action, even if the agent's motive is the hope of a reward, a motive of little virtue admittedly.

 In other words, one should not confuse the morality of actions and the value of agents, even if the moral value of a person logically derives from all of his actions. And it is ultimately easier to assess the morality of an action, the intention of which is often quite clear, than its motive (s), which may be unclear - the hope for heaven may be a part reason for a good deed done by a believer. 

 Mill recognizes that some utilitarian - he thinks, without naming him, of Bentham - do not care enough, if at all, about the value of the agent. However, the value judgment made on the agent is not a judgment of morality, since it is not rational: it is a matter of feeling.

Isn't utilitarian philosophy a philosophy without God (objection 7)?

Without answering the question of the existence of God itself, Mill replies that utilitarianism is compatible with the existence of God - it is also compatible, even if he does not specify it, with its non-existence. Doesn't God want the happiness of his creatures more than all? Moreover, nothing in the various revelations can be judged as being incompatible with the principles of utilitarian morality. 

 It is unnecessary to wonder any further whether revelation, Christian for example, is useful in interpreting the will of God in matters of morality. Everyone can rely on, or not, on religion, in moral matters as in other matters.

Doesn't utilitarian philosophy lead human beings to always act self-interested (objection 8)?

Mill responds to this objection by carefully distinguishing between useful and expedient. We have seen that utility as a utilitarian criterion is in no way that of the agent alone, a fortiori if he acts to the detriment of others. The utility should always be measured on the scale of the greatest happiness for all. Any opportune action, accomplished by doing an undeserved harm to others, is contrary to utilitarian morality. 

 So it is with a lie. It is often a good idea to lie to get out of a sticky situation. But, considered on the scale of humanity or even of society, lying causes great harm to the extent that it weakens the trust between men, on which life in society rests. Only very specific circumstances, in which the consequences of lying are less harmful than those of a sincere statement - if lying saves the life of an innocent person, for example - can therefore justify morally, from a utilitarian point of view. 

 Isn't utilitarian philosophy impossible to put into practice in the urgency of action (objection 9)?

Such an objection, according to Mill, is either stupidity or bad faith. In many cases, no reflection is necessary to know whether an action is moral or not - not only in the utilitarian sense, moreover: so is the case with murder, for example.

 

 In less obvious cases, it is the cumulative experience of all humanity that we must take as our guide. Of course, this experience is not infallible, and there is certainly much progress to be made in moral philosophy. But this can in no way serve as a pretext for a supposed inability to act morally. Mill distinguishes here the "first principle" and the "secondary principles". The first principle fixes the happiness of the greatest number as the goal of morality. The secondary principles are those which will allow us, in an empirical and therefore perfectible way, to achieve this goal. That the latter are not certain does not exempt us from either practicing or improving them.

Does utilitarian philosophy not provide fallacious arguments in case of moral dilemma for violating moral rules (objection 10)?

This objection is based on the fact that, as we have seen, utilitarian morality does not set forth moral rules capable of being applied universally. Depending on the cases, the same attitude can be moral or immoral, and thus seems to open the door to hypocritical casuistry - treatment on a case-by-case basis, depending on community or private interests. This is also the case with the rule against lying (see objection 8). But this objection should in reality be addressed to any moral system, for human affairs are so complex that it is in reality impossible to state truly universal moral rules. Thus, Kantian morality, forbidding lies whatever the circumstances, 

 If utilitarianism does not provide a "turnkey" morality, applicable without discernment, it nevertheless provides, with the criterion of utility, a clear tool of moral distinction if it is applied honestly.

Conclusion

Utilitarian morality is founded on the principle of the greatest happiness for all. An action is all the more moral the more it aims at this end. The happiness in humans differs from satisfaction, which are capable of other animals, in that it consists in particular active pleasures resulting from the deployment of the higher faculties of the mind, and only to a lesser extent passive and bodily pleasures. 

 Mill particularly insists on the fact that utilitarian morality fixes as the goal of human actions the happiness of the greatest number and not that of the agent alone. That is why the dedication and even the sacrifice of one for the happiness of others constitute behaviors perfectly in accordance with utilitarian philosophy. It is therefore only through a misinterpretation of the latter that it is supposed to be incompatible with disinterestednes— its opposition to Kant's morality is on this point much less than is often believed. 

 In order to know whether an action is moral, Mill therefore proposes the following criterion: was this action taken with the rational intention of generally allowing or increasing the happiness of the greatest number, or is it at least compatible with the happiness of those it concerns? To answer this question, it is not necessary to know the emotional motives, sometimes vague, of the agent, this criterion also has the advantage of being compatible with all positions relating to religionsObjections to utilitarianism, and of being easily applicable in the daily existence of human beings.

Author: Vicki Lezama


Comments

Need a custom
essay?

We will write it for you.
Order now

Free Essay Examples

Free essays:

All you need to know about Neuroendocrinology
All you need to know about Big data management
All you need to know about digital special effects
All you need to know Technical Writing?
Basics the Game Theory in Cryptoeconomics
Business innovation ideas for making money
Biosensors for cancer diagnosis
Business Analysis: Pricing strategies and Demand Curve
Cognitive Computing- How does Cognitive Computing work?
Consciousness: characteristics and peculiarities
Conservation Economics
Cybersecurity in business: challenges, risks, and practices
Demographic trends and how they affect Economic Growth
Dance as an art form and entertainment
Discrimination Economics
Determinants of Wages
Everything you need to know about short-term memory
Economic and Policy Impacts of Demographics
Ethics: an essay on the understanding of evil
Emotions: what are they? Theories explained
Factors of Demographic Data Collection
Factors Affecting Purchasing Behavior
Financial Statement Analysis
Factors Influencing Interest and Exchange Rates
Government's Intervention in The Labor Market
Guide on the Pathways of the nervous system
Game theory in microeconomics
Globalization: definition, causes, social impact and risks
How Relativism Promotes Pluralism and Tolerance
How to use the audience’s feedback to write a news report
History of silent cinema
How news report can be strengthened through multimedia
Introduction to Population Problems
Imperfect Information and Asymmetric Information
Imperfect Information in Insurance
Introduction to Labor Markets
Journalism: What is News?
Journalism: Broadcast media and Television Presenters
Journalism: Sources of News
Journalism and Law
Key Determinants of National Income
Key Factors That Affect Pricing Decisions
Kinetic models in biology and Related fields
Know about the different forms of traditional African dances
Latest technology trends
Latest dance trends
Magnetoencephalography (MEG)
Microeconomic Analysis to the Demand for Labor
Neuromuscular disorders
National Economies, Fluctuation, and Responses to Fluctuations
Neurotransmitters: what they are and different types
Nanomedicines to target tumors
Objections to utilitarianism
Organizational motivation and its effects
Overcoming Hiring Challenges for Nonprofit Organization
Population Demographics
Russian School of Mathematics
Research and Development
Risk Sharing in Insurance and Asset Markets
Risk and the value of information
Structure of the nervous system
Structure of a Corporation
Schizoaffective disorder: how to live better with it
Segregation in the US.
The climate change denial
The techniques of basic cinematography
The Endosymbiotic Theory
The Role of Internal Audit in Corporate Risk Management
Unions
Unemployment
Utilitarianism Vs. Kantianism
Understanding Auctions and Auction Theory: Part 2
Various theoretical perspectives of sociology
Virtual reality, what it is and how it works
What is Relativism?
What is TES-Transcranial electrical stimulation?
4 Facts about Origin of Mathematics!
5 techniques to create an animation
10 emerging technologies according to World Economic Forum
10 strategies to maximize corporate profits
3d Model Of Building
6 Medical Technologies that revolutionized the healthcare in 2020
All you need to know about the ACA Code of ethics
Architecture and Democracy: An Introduction
Architecture and Democracy: Democratic Values
Architecture and Democracy: Democratic Procedures
All You Need to Know About a Synthesis Essay
An essential guide to understanding Film Theory
Application of Artificial Intelligence in Cyber Security
Applications of electrical engineering
Augmented reality: what it is, how it works, examples
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Social Networking
All you need to know about Cryptography
Applications of astrophysical science
All you need to know about architecture engineering
Applications of geological engineering
Artificial intelligence and medicine: an increasingly close relationship
An insight into Computational Biology
ACA code of conduct
A Rose for Emily
Applications of Mathematics in daily life
Architecture mistakes to avoid
All you need to know about Toxicology
All you need to know about Holistic Medicine
All you need to know about linguistics
An introduction to Linguistics and its subfields
All you need to know about Anxiety disorder
All you need to know about Drones
A Brief Insight into Political Science
Assumptions related to feminism
All you need to know about Byzantine emperors
All you need to know about labour economics
An insight into xenobots -the first-ever robots
An ultimate guide about Biomaterials
A Comprehensive Introduction to the Mona Lisa
Analysis methods of Transport through biological membranes
An ultimate guide about biochemical reactions
Analysis of brain signals
Artificial Gene Synthesis
Application to synthetic biology of CAD methods
All you need to know about metabolic pathways
Applications of BIOMEMS
All you need to know about the epidemiology
Asian vs. western leadership styles
All you need to know about Smart prosthesis
Analysis of Economy: Output of Goods and Services (GNP), and GDP on Economic success
A Guide to Pricing Strategies
An Overview Of Economic Studies
Analysis of Fiscal and Monetary Policies
Analysis of Business Cycles
Analysis of Consumption and Investment
A Look into Regression Analysis
Analysis of Household's Consumption and Savings Behavior
All you need to know about Capital Budgeting
All you need to know about risk management
Art looted in wartime.
Appropriate use of Data in Economics
All you need to know about reaction kinetics?
A historical overview of Financial Crises
All you need to know about management discipline?
An insight into the error-correction models
All you need to know about Data visualization
All you need to know about Work-family balance
All you need to know Technical Writing?
All you need to know about digital special effects
All you need to know about Big data management
All you need to know about Neuroendocrinology
How to Write a Personal Essay
Housing Needs in America
How to Write a Description Essay
How to Create an Excellent Scholarship Essay?
How to write a cause and effect essay
How to Hire the Best Essay Writing Service Provider?
How to Write a College Application Essay?
How to get the most out of your English lectures
How to write Expository Essay
How to succeed in your psychology class?
How to Write an Academic Essay in the Shortest Time?
History of Journalism
How Different Sectors are Using Artificial intelligence (AI)
How to write an informative essay
How to deliver persuasive essays?
How to Give a Convincing Presentation
How to write an essay on leadership?
Historical Art Still Around Today
Humanoid robot: what it is, how it works and price
History of Chemistry
Healthcare Advanced Computer Power: Robotics, Medical Imaging, and More
Healthcare AI: Game Changers for Medical Decision-Making and Remote Patient Monitoring
How to understand different types of English
How to Cope with Chronic Pain
How African American choreographers and dancers have influenced American dance
How mobile robot can do in logistics or in production
How To Become a Successful Entrepreneur
History of the Philosophy of Feminism
How is the climate changing?
How to Track Your Content Marketing ROI
How to Gun control In the USA?
Historical and contemporary role of labour in the modern world
How breast cancers are classified?
How the cells of our body communicate?
How the Lymphatic System Works?
How Digestive System Works
How to complete your capstone projects effectively?
How to write a research project
Healthcare technologies that help patients with better self-management
How to choose the topic of the senior capstone project
How to make your business survive at economic crisis
How can immigrants blend in the American society?
How does the economics of war affect society?
Hate speech on social media.
How to Build an Economic Model
How to start a healthcare startup?
How can financial illiteracy harm you?
How cancer is developed - Cancer biology
How to define the Enterprise Value
How to conduct economic research?
How women can manage sexual harassment
How to use quotes in your news reports?
How news report can be strengthened through multimedia
History of silent cinema
How to use the audience’s feedback to write a news report
How Relativism Promotes Pluralism and Tolerance
Introduction to Urban Studies
Importance of dance in education
InMoov: how to build an open source humanoid robot
Importance of KYC verification to making the Blockchain secure
Importance of Rhythm
Importance of dance student evaluation
I/O control methods -types and explanations
Identity theft: what to do?
Introduction to Utilitarianism
Importance of 3d Modelling in Architecture
Importance of online journalism
Image processing in medical diagnosis
Introduction to USA Politics
Introduction to Comparative Politics
International Relations as a Major in Political Science
Importance of modern trade policy
Introduction to Journalism
Introduction to Writing a TV Script
Introduction of Microfabrication techniques
Introduction to Microeconomics
Interaction of Consumer and Firm Choices in Markets
Importance of corporate sustainability
Issues in International Monetary Macroeconomics
Introduction to Statistics and Data for Economics
Introduction to Data and Probability for Economics
Introduction to the Game Theory
Introduction to Econometrics
Introduction to Economic Information
Introduction to Market Equilibrium
Introduction to Economic Models and Application
Introduction to Empirical Research
Introduction to Econometric Data
Importance of Critical Thinking, Principles, and Goals
Introduction to Identification and Causal inferences
Introduction to Econometric Application
Intermediaries and Government in Financial Crisis
Importance and seven principles of quality management
Illiteracy in the USA
Introduction to Economics of Law
Introduction to Coase Theorem
Introduction to Social Choice and Incarceration
Intellectual Property and Product Liability
Investment in Human Capital
Introduction to Labor Markets
Imperfect Information in Insurance
Imperfect Information and Asymmetric Information
Introduction to Population Problems
The Looming Energy Crisis in America
Top benefits of performance-based engineering
The More Languages You Know, The More Times You Are a Man
Things to consider while writing an Argumentative Essay
Top Ways to Improve Your Academic Writing Skills
Tips to Excel in Creative Writing
The origins of films in the early 19th century
Top career options in Architecture
The Elevator Pitch
Top finance trends 2020
The basic Structure and functionality of robots
The Way to Success
The election system of the President in the United States of America
Two-party System in United States of America
Top trends in urban design
The history and theory of African American filmmaking
Top benefits of creative writing
Tinnitus Guide: Common Symptoms and Treatment Options
The language of dance
The digital image processing management
Top famous politicians of the World
Top methods of political science!
The history of the feminist movement
The blood flow in cardiovascular system - Biofluid Mechanics
The best of Leonardo Da Vinci
The Structure and Function of Macromolecules
The structure of cell: a research on the bricks of the human body!
Tissue and organ construction: Adhesion and recognition between cells
The kinetics of the transformation processes
The Modeling of Biological Systems
Tips for writing a great thesis statement
The Defense mechanisms against infections
The impact of the technological innovations in medicine
Top journalism trends to know about
The relation between mass media & politics
Theranostics: Diagnosis and Care through Nanoparticles
The practical Applications of X-rays
The applications of Ultrasound in medicine
Transfer mechanisms of genetic information in Bacteria
The regulation of cellular metabolism in the diagnosis
The Principles of MRI Contrast agents
The technical basis of optical coherence imaging
The New Media: Emerging Trends
The Structure of Interest Rates and the Yield Curve
Technological perspectives and reflections of neural engineering
Types of bioreactors and their applications
The Role of Government Policy in Improving Economic Outcomes
Types of corporate responsibility
The Role of IMF in International Monetary Macroeconomics
Tools for investment decision making
The concept of Organizational Culture and its applications
The Conduct of Monetary and Fiscal Policy
The Basics of Financial Accelerator Models
Tips for labeling medical devices- Medical Entrepreneurship
The different medical imaging techniques
The Economics of Uncertainty – Introduction
Theories of Public Policy
The Game Theory in Social Media
The political theory of Thomas Hobbes
The Use of Law on Economics and Vice Versa
The Role of Internal Audit in Corporate Risk Management
The Endosymbiotic Theory
The techniques of basic cinematography
The climate change denial
What is a Definition Essay?
What are diagnostic essays?
What is the relation between art structural engineering?
What is a Narrative Essay
What are robotics and intelligence systems?
What are the benefits of studying health sciences?
What is artificial intelligence and why it matters?
What is comparative Literature?
Why study neuroscience
What is Wi-Fi and how does it works
What is French history famous for?
What are Humanistic Studies?
What is covered in Biophysics?
What is modern journalism?
What is Virtualization? Benefits & Applications
What are modern public relations?
What is plasma physics?
What is teacher preparation?
What is rapid prototyping for 3D printing?
What is contemporary European Politics?
Why should you learn American Ballet?
What is engineering physics?
What is the purpose of African American Literature?
Ways to learn the Rhythm
What is digital art used for?
What are Enzymes and how do they work
Who is the father of political science?
Why Study Political Science - Job?
What is the Philosophy of Feminism?
What is a quantum computer?
Ways B2B Startups Streamline Their Conversion Strategies
Why do biomedical signals need processing?
What are the long term effects of climate change?
Why study labour relations
What is Holoprosencephaly?
What is antisocial disorder?
What are the important principles of evolution?
What is the cytoplasm and its function?
What is biopolymers?
What Makes a Good Leader
Women empowerment in modern generation
What is the history of political thought?
What is Gene recombination
What is synthetic biology
What is business cost analysis?
What is Inflation
What are the consequences of unemployment?
What is lithotripsy and its types?
What is transition elastography?
What is the purpose of deep brain stimulation?
What is a Brain-Computer Interface (BCI)
What is neuroethics?
What is Market and Supply and Demand
What is optogenetics?
What are the techniques to record brain activity?
What happens if the interest rate increases?
What is immunotherapy?
What is the economic role of the financial market?
What are the factors behind illegal immigration?
What is the lymphocyte activation?
What is financial market and its types?
What is the structure of financial markets?
What are the methods of measuring business performance?
What is the Credit market?
What is business ethics and code of ethics
What are the Causes of financial instability?
What is MBA with Concentrations
What is regenerative medicine?
What is Population ecology?
What is Microfinance: evolution, and practices?
What is biotechnology and its applications?
What are Workplace diversity and its benefits?
What is the difference between a leader and a manager?
What Is Branding and best branding Business strategies?
Why are microelectronics important?
What are biologic drugs.
What is the Foreign Exchange market?
What is the role of scientific research in times of crisis?
What are the risks of international trade?
What is financial management?
What is gene therapy?
What is education economics?
What is regression analysis, and why should you use it?
What Is Technology Marketing And How Should It Work?
What is Management Accounting
What are the methods of valuation of companies?
What is Immune System and Immunotherapy?
What is big data analytics?
What is the 7 layers of OSI model?
What is Neuroplasticity?
What are Sculpture art and its types?
What are the different genres of films?
What is Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS)?
What is TES-Transcranial electrical stimulation?
What is Relativism?